BACKGROUND ON THE FORMATION OF
ST. THOMAS LODGE NO. 9679 E.C.
BY
RHYS S. HODGE, PAGDC, ADGM
FOUNDING MASTER
It was truly an historic occasion when a new Lodge was consecrated on St. Thomas, to
meet on St. Thomas, United States Virgin Islands. This occurred on Friday, November 13,
1998, when a consecrating team lead by the Immediate Past District Grand Master, R. W.
Bro. Dr. William E. Cooper, the present District Grand Master, R.W. Bro. Brian Douglas
Parsons, and other senior District Grand Lodge officers conscrecrated St. Thomas Lodge No.
9679 in St. Thomas United States Virgin Islands. While Friday the 13th is generally
regarded as an unlucky day, the founders of St. Thomas Lodge No. 9679 E.C., are instead
betting that it will be a lucky day for freemansory in St. Thomas in general and for the
new St. Thomas Lodge in particular. The formation of St. Thomas Lodge 9679 continues a
long tradition of English freemasonry in the Virgin Islands.
The first evidence of Freemasonry in the former Danish West Indies, comprising St.
Thomas, St. Croix and St. John, was in 1756 when St. George Lodge No. 224 was chartered on
St. Croix by the Grand Lodge of England. The last returns on the Grand Lodge Register for
this lodge, which in 1766 was renumbered 216, was in 1814. There is also evidence that in
1777 the Grand Lodge of England installed one John Ryan as Provincial Grand Master for St.
Croix without any other lodges being founded there. On St. Thomas, a Danish lodge
chartered by the Directorium in Copenhagen (Scottish Lodge Directorium) and known as Unity
Lodge, later changed to "St. Thomas to Unity Lodge" was consecrated December 3,
1798. From its records, the last meeting of this lodge appear to have been June 8, 1808.
The former lodge building of the St. Thomas to Unity Lodge at the foot of Fireburn Hill
was recently renovated and is now used by the Council on Alcoholism and is presently known
as the "Old Unity Lodge Building." It is of passing interest that the
name of our new lodge, consists in part of the name of the former "St. Thomas to
Unity Lodge".
Because the Danish Lodges in the Virgin Islands, " To the Holy Cross" in St.
Croix and "St. Thomas to Unity" during its existence on St. Thomas, did not
readily admit free Blacks or Jews as members, a petition was made to the Grand Lodge of
England for a new lodge and Harmonic Lodge No. 708, now 356, was founded on October 19,
1818. Harmonic Lodge, however, was to meet in St. Thomas, Danish West Indies for which the
special permission was obtained from the Danish Governor General. Harmonic Lodge No. 356
became the only English lodge on American soil in 1917 when the United States purchased
the Virgin Islands from Denmark. Harmonic Lodge prospered and for many years its
membership regularly exceeded 150 members. Attempts to obtained a second charter from the
Grand Lodge of England for St. Thomas or St. Croix proved unsuccessful. The Grand Lodge
would not issue a new charter for a lodge on America territory. In fact, the last lodge
chartered by the Grand Lodge of England in an American jurisdiction was African Lodge No.
459 in 1784 to Prince Hall and others in Boston. Brethren on St. Croix not being able to
receive a charter form the Grand Lodge of England, formed Caribbean Light Lodge No. 101
under the Grand Lodge of Puerto Rico. The same result followed with efforts to form
another English Royal Arch Chapter. St. Croix members of Caribbean Light Lodge joined the
English Royal Arch Chapter attached to Harmonic Lodge, Zetland Chapter No. 356. Several
St. Croix brethren were allowed to serve a principals in Zetland in order to petition for
an English Chapter, again without success.
With Harmonics membership continually exceeding 150 members and a long list of
candidates awaiting initiation, coupled with dispensations increasingly granted for
special meetings and to initiate, pass or raise more than two candidates at a time, it was
clear that in order to maintain the interest of candidates and members , a new lodge was
needed to relieve the pressures on Harmonic. A personal appeal was made to the District
Grand Master, R.W. Bro. Dr. William E. Cooper, to intercede with Grand Lodge to achieve a
reversal of its prior policy of not considering a new lodge on St. Thomas, a Territory of
United States. The R.W. Bro. Copper personally, and with the able assistance of the then
District Grand Secretary and now District Grand Master, R. Wor. Bro.. B.D. Parsons,
presented our case to Grand Lodge. By letter dated May 22, 1995, Grand Secretary finally
advised that in view of Harmonic s existence from 1818 on St. Thomas without any
other recognized constitution being present, Grand Lodge was inclined to grant the request
of the brethren in St. Thomas for a new lodge. A petition form was provided together with
instructions and a form of draft by-laws. That petition form was signed by twenty-two (22)
petitioners and submitted to Grand Lodge by cover letter dated May 18, 1998. The petition
was granted in principle at Grand Lodges quarterly meeting on June 10, 1998, but
being cautious, Grand Lodge first desired to determine if any other Grand Authority
objected to the petition. Grand Lodge therefore wrote to the Grand Lodge of Puerto Rico,
as the nearest Grand Lodge to St. Thomas advising of the petition and inquiring if it had
any objection to the formation of the new lodge on St. Thomas. By letter dated September
11, 1998, the Grand Secretary of the Grand Lodge of Puerto Rico responded that the Grand
Lodge of Puerto Rico, had no lodge on St. Thomas, and therefore had no objection to the
Grand Lodge of England forming a daughter lodge to Harmonic 356 which has existed on St.
Thomas for 180 years. On October 15, 1998, Grand Secretary officially advised that as
there were no objections to its forming a new lodge on St. Thomas, the petition had been
granted, and the new "St. Thomas Lodge" would bear the number ''9679''.
The founding master and wardens designated in the petition are Master, Rhys S. Hodge,
PAGDC, ADGM, Senior Warden, Leroy L. Marchena, PDSGW and Junior Warden, John P. Woods. The
new St. Thomas Lodge No. 9679 was consecrated on November 13, 1998, at 2:00 p.m., in a
specially created temple at the Mariotts Frenchmans Reef Hotel on St. Thomas,
U.S. Virgin Islands. Over one hundred brethren from every one of the 16 other lodgess in
the District were present at the consecration, together with representatives from the
Grand Lodge of Puerto Rico and the District Grand Master of the District Grand Lodge of
Bahamas and Turks, R.W. Bro. Peter D. Cole. R.W. Bro. Dr. Cooper, PDGM, having worked
diligently to see the petition to fruition , certainly took much pleasure in serving as
the Consecrating Officer at the consecration of the new lodge. The officers and founders
of St. Thomas Lodge No. 9679, sincerely appreciate the assistance of all who have
contributed to its creation, particularly the brethren of Harmonic Lodge, 356, its
sponsor.